Compare Home Care Services

When selecting personalized home care assistance for a loved one, it’s hard to know how to evaluate your options. For many people it’s their first time seeking in home care assistance. Services are typically provided by one of three different methods including Full Service Home Care Agencies, Employment Agencies and Private Hire Independent Agency Contractors.

  • Full Service Home Care Agencies – Water Tower Nursing Home Care (WTN) is a full service Home Services Agency licensed to operate in Illinois, serving the greater Chicago area. Full service agencies offer the broadest service level including being responsible for payment of all wages, employment taxes and unemployment insurance including the withholding of applicable social security, federal and state taxes for all home service workers (caregivers).
  • Employment Agencies – Services offered by employment agencies vary from agency to agency. Often they are helping you identify a potential caregiver but their responsibilities may not go much beyond the location of the individual. You should check carefully to understand who is responsible for withholding taxes and verifying authorization to work in the USA. You may also be responsible for screening and checking references as well as securing liability insurance and workers’ compensation insurance.
  • Private Hire Independent Agency Contractor – When working with an individual or private hire independent agency contractor you are essentially the employer and carry most of the burden for hiring and managing the caregiver. Liability may be handled by either party but is most commonly the responsibility of the hiring party.

Contact Us

We welcome the opportunity to show you the difference that our team of professionals at Water Tower Nursing and Home Care can make in the lives of those that are most important to us.

Call us today at: 312.280.4980

We’re conveniently located at:
Water Tower Place
The Professional Suites
845 N. Michigan Ave.
Chicago, IL

Compare Your Choices

 

Full Service Agency
(Water Tower Nursing)

Employment Agency

Private Hire Independent Agency Contractor

FIND THE RIGHT CAREGIVER

Locate, screen, interview and train

Yes

?

Client Responsibility

Check employer references

Yes

?

Client Responsibility

Verify USA work authorization

Yes

?

Client Responsibility

Withhold payroll taxes

Yes

?

Client Responsibility

Determine work schedule, cover days off & holidays

Yes

Client Responsibility

Client Responsibility

SUPERVISION

Professional on-site supervision

Yes

Client Responsibility

Client Responsibility

Caregiver replacement, if necessary

Yes

?

Client Responsibility

LIABILITY

Workers’ compensation insurance

Yes

Client Responsibility?/Possible joint Responsibility

Independent Contractor or Client Responsibility

Payroll requirements (Social Security, Payroll Tax, Unemployment Insurance, Works’ Compensation, etc.)

Yes

Client Responsibility?/Possible joint Responsibility

Client Responsibility (if worker does not meet IRS independent contractor status)

Professional liability insurance or bond for caregiver

Yes

?

Independent Contractor or Client Responsibility

SAFETY RISK LEVEL

Client lives alone, supportive family not available (vulnerable client)

Agency Supervision, Risk Reduced

No Agency Supervision, No Reduction of Risk

Unknown: dependent on pre-hire screening, only client supervision

Client lives alone, has impaired judgement. Family concerned, but cannot supervise caregiver. (most vulnerable client)

Agency Supervision, Risk Reduced

No Agency Supervision, No Reduction of Risk

Unknown: dependent on pre-hire screening, only client supervision

Client lives alone, family willing to supervise caregiver and provide care as needed. (least vulnerable client)

Agency Supervision, Risk Reduced

Family Supervision, Risk Reduced

Unknown: dependent on pre-hire screening, only family supervision

COST COMPARISON

Illinois Labor Law requires employers to pay at least 1 1/2 times the regular hourly rate of pay for over 40 hours in a work week. Live-in employees must have at least 24 consecutive hours of rest every calendar week.

Rates typically higher than employment agency or private hire/independent contractor

Client may pay a one-time placement fee, along with possible taxes

May be a cost effective alternative if client & responsible parties are aware of risks and payroll, insurance and liabilities

Know the Questions to Ask

Download your personalized Home Care Services – Compare Your Choices Worksheet (PDF). It’s filled with questions to ask prospective home care service providers during your initial interview. This resource outlines many of the differences between available services. Use it to help guide you in your evaluation of your options.